Records
Every wrestler with four or more NCAA titles
7 wrestlers have won four or more NCAA Division I titles, and Carter Starocci of Penn State won 5 (2021–2025), the most in the record.
| Wrestler | School | Titles | Title years and weights | NCAA record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carter Starocci | Penn State | 5 | 2021 174 lb · 2022 174 lb · 2023 174 lb · 2024 174 lb · 2025 184 lb | 25–0 |
| Pat Smith | Oklahoma State | 4 | 1990 158 lb · 1991 158 lb · 1992 158 lb · 1994 158 lb | 21–0 |
| Cael Sanderson | Iowa State | 4 | 1999 184 lb · 2000 184 lb · 2001 184 lb · 2002 197 lb | 20–0 |
| Kyle Dake | Cornell (NY) | 4 | 2010 141 lb · 2011 149 lb · 2012 157 lb · 2013 165 lb | 20–0 |
| Logan Stieber | Ohio State | 4 | 2012 133 lb · 2013 133 lb · 2014 141 lb · 2015 141 lb | 20–0 |
| John 'Yianni' Diakomihalis | Cornell (NY) | 4 | 2018 141 lb · 2019 141 lb · 2022 149 lb · 2023 149 lb | 20–0 |
| Aaron Brooks | Penn State | 4 | 2021 184 lb · 2022 184 lb · 2023 184 lb · 2024 197 lb | 20–0 |
A title is a weight-class championship at the NCAA Division I championships, 1928–2026; no tournament was held in 1943–1945 (World War II) or 2020 (COVID-19). The NCAA record counts every bout at the championships, as each wrestler page does.